Blog

Sarah Carey for the Irish Independent: People with mental illness need a safe place, they can’t live on streets or in jail

Sarah Carey writes for the Irish Independent about the recent RTÉ Investigates two-part documentary on the criminalisation of mental illness in Ireland and the cruelty of a criminal justice system that is not equipped to provide dignity and care to those who suffer from mental illness.

Read highlights from the article below, and read the article in full (behind a paywall) on the Irish Independent website here.

On how the situation in Ireland has reached this point:

Why is this horrible situation allowed to go on? Because we are prisoners of history and ideology. First, the history.

Mental asylums were closed down because mass incarceration resulted in terrible wrongs and deprivation of rights.

As psychiatrist Brendan Kelly told RTÉ, at one stage Ireland had over 20,000 people in mental hospitals, more patients per capita than any other country in the world.

When the hospitals were closed, we were told patients would get care in the community. The “community” turned out to be the streets. It was a disaster.

 

On the Mental Health Bill 2024:

Back in Ireland, the Mental Health Bill is slowly working its way through the Oireachtas.

The original version doubled down on the ideology by forcing psychiatrists to go to court to get permission to treat patients. I brought the concerns of psychiatrists to public attention and hundreds of amendments have been made in the Seanad and Dáil.

The College of Psychiatrists of Ireland acknowledges that junior health minister Mary Butler and her team are doing enormous work in drafting the legislation in such a way that it balances personal autonomy with the person’s right to access timely treatment.

However, they told me they remain concerned about court oversight of clinical treatment and are particularly disturbed by the introduction of a definition of pharmacological restraint; “a practice that is simply not engaged in.” It shouldn’t be like this.

When it came to abortion we were told that doctors, not lawyers, should decide on women’s care. The same is true for psychiatry.